The Healthcare Racket: How Billing Exhaustion Became the Business Model

A personal story about healthcare billing, surprise medical bills, and how insurance complexity became a business model built on exhaustion.

I’ve reached a point where I’m convinced the American healthcare billing system isn’t merely broken. It is designed to wear people down until they stop asking questions and just pay.

And maybe that’s the point.

Over the past few months I’ve dealt with billing issues around a preventive colonoscopy, a liver elastography scan, and a transthoracic echocardiogram. None of these were luxury procedures. None were elective vanity treatments. These were preventive screenings and medically recommended diagnostics meant to help catch serious problems early.

Gritty illustration of a man standing in a maze of medical bills insurance claims deductibles and denied healthcare charges representing the complexity of American healthcare billing
In America’s healthcare maze, the bill is never the bill.

The kind of care we are constantly told to prioritize.

Get screened early. Be proactive. Take care of your health.

So I did.

And I walked straight into one of the most absurd customer experiences I have ever encountered.

The Price Is Never the Price

Before scheduling my liver scan and echocardiogram, I did what responsible adults are told to do. I called around. I gathered CPT codes. I contacted billing departments. I compared prices.

Five different locations gave me wildly different numbers for the exact same procedures.

Not slightly different.

Wildly different.

One quoted around $400. Another quoted nearly $3,600.

Same procedure. Same insurance. Same region.

A 9x difference.

How is that even defensible?

Worse, no facility offered both procedures, so coordinating care became a logistical puzzle on top of a financial guessing game.

After hours of calls and conflicting answers, I chose the main local hospital because it seemed like the safest option. Even then, their own billing department gave me two completely different price estimates on separate calls.

Same hospital. Same codes. Different answers.

So on the day of service, I asked one final time.

I asked: “Is this the full bill? No surprise charges later?”

I explained that I had already received conflicting numbers from their billing department and wanted to make sure there would be nothing else coming.

The staff told me yes.

They even offered a 20% discount if I paid at time of service.

That sounds reassuring, right?

Pay now, save money, move on.

So I paid.

How Billing Exhaustion Became the Business Model

Then the bills came.

Not from the hospital.

From the radiologists.

Separate charges for specialists to interpret the scans and diagnose the findings.

In other words, the bill I was assured was the full bill… wasn’t the full bill.

And this keeps happening.

The American healthcare billing system doesn’t merely overcharge patients…it exhausts them. Through confusing codes, fragmented systems, and endless billing loops, patients become unpaid project managers in a system designed to wear them down until they stop asking questions and just pay.

Ran Kime

My preventive colonoscopy was supposed to be fully covered. That’s what insurance told me. Later I received a pathology bill because the polyps removed during the procedure had to be examined.

Insurance told me pathology connected to preventive colonoscopies is covered.

Then they told me it wasn’t.

Then they told me it depends on diagnostic codes.

Then they told me to call the provider.

The provider told me to call insurance.

Insurance told me their systems don’t talk to each other.

The pathology company said they’re reviewing the appeal.

Bills continue arriving anyway.

The Loop: Call Insurance, Call Billing, Repeat

I Was Caught in “The Loop”

At some point you stop feeling like a patient and start feeling like the unpaid project manager of a failing enterprise software implementation.

And maybe that’s what bothers me most.

I’m a UX Architect by trade. I think about systems, workflows, trust, and user journeys for a living.

This system fails every basic principle of good design.

There is no transparency.
There is no single source of truth.
There is no ownership.
There is no predictable outcome.

The customer—you, the patient—is forced to stitch together fragmented information from providers, hospitals, specialists, labs, and insurers who all operate inside disconnected systems.

If Amazon worked like this, they’d collapse.

Imagine buying a laptop online.

Checkout says paid in full.

Two weeks later:

  • Packaging Fee: $62
  • Device Verification Fee: $143
  • Quality Assurance Review Fee: $188

You call support.

Retail says call warehouse.
Warehouse says call manufacturer.
Manufacturer says call payment processor.
Payment processor says they only process what was submitted.

No one owns the outcome.

That is healthcare.

And here’s the insult layered on top of the dysfunction.

My employer and I collectively pay over $24,000 per year for health insurance.

Twenty-four thousand dollars.

Yet every scan feels like a casino.

Every test feels like rolling dice.

Every bill feels like waiting for a trap door to open.

The emotional cost isn’t talked about enough.

People talk about deductibles and premiums.

They don’t talk about the exhaustion.

The endless calls.
The contradictory answers.
The feeling that no matter how responsible, diligent, or prepared you are, the system still wins.

Eventually you understand something unsettling: This system doesn’t need to deny everyone. It only needs to confuse people long enough that they give up.

And many do.

Why Patients Stop Fighting

Because after your tenth phone call over a $154 bill, you start asking yourself whether your sanity is worth more than the money.

That may be the most effective billing strategy ever invented.

Not denial.

Exhaustion.

That is the part nobody says out loud.

Healthcare doesn’t just drain wallets.

It drains patience.
It drains trust.
It drains mental bandwidth.

And when trust goes, something bigger breaks.

Because once people stop believing they can safely seek care without financial ambush, they delay care altogether.

That’s the real cost.

Not just the bill.

The fear of the next one.

So What Exactly Are We Supposed to Do?

Write our members of Congress and hope someone reads the letter before we’re added to another fundraising list to subsidize their next campaign—or their next well-timed stock trade?

File complaints with state insurance departments and trust that our story becomes more than another case number in a database?

Email our employer’s HR department and ask them to pressure the insurance carriers they negotiate with every year?

Who actually owns fixing this?

Because from where I sit, every path feels like another support loop.

Call insurance.
Call the provider.
Call billing.
File an appeal.
Wait 30 to 45 days.
Receive another bill anyway.

Repeat.

That same loop seems to exist at every level of the system.

Patients tell providers.
Providers blame insurers.
Insurers cite billing codes.
Employers negotiate premiums.
Politicians promise reform.
Lobbyists protect incentives.

And around it all sits a machine so large and fragmented that accountability dissolves into process.

Maybe that is the most dangerous part of all.

Not greed.
Not even cost.

Helplessness.

The slow normalization of learned helplessness.

The belief that nothing changes, so why bother trying?

I don’t have the answer.

But I know this:

Silence guarantees nothing changes.

So maybe the first step is speaking plainly and often.

Tell your story.
File the complaint.
Write the letter.
Challenge the bill.
Push back against the absurdity.

Because if enough of us keep saying the same thing—loudly enough, consistently enough—eventually someone has to listen.

At least, I hope so.

If I ran a business the way healthcare and insurance operate, I’d be out of business.

Tell customers one price. Bill them another. Hide costs behind opaque codes, disconnected systems, and endless support loops. Force them to spend hours doing the coordination your own systems should handle.

No other industry could survive operating like this.

And how much money changes hands this way every year?

Millions?

Billions?

How much is overbilled, miscoded, duplicated, or simply paid because patients never catch the error?

How much gets collected not because the charges are necessarily correct, but because people are exhausted?

Because that may be the most profitable part of the system.

They know most people won’t fight.

Some won’t read the bill.
Some won’t understand it.
Some won’t know who to call.
Some won’t have the time.
And many will decide their sanity is worth more than spending ten hours chasing answers through automated phone trees, outsourced support centers, and disconnected departments.

The system doesn’t need every bill to be right.

It only needs enough people to give up.

The insurance racket is exactly that—a racket.

Legalized organized crime dressed in policy documents, billing codes, and corporate pleasantries.